Among the many challenges that come with a capitalistic nation, there exists a rising insecurity with the falling birth rate— a phenomenon that doesn't sit well with the nation's desire to have unlimited labor available for a limited budget. As a remnant of a colonial machinery, capitalism fails to meet its claims. With limited resources, job insecurities, non-existent work-life balance, gender disparities, unaddressed mental health, questionable healthcare, rising rates of illiteracy, unstable relationships, residents of capitalistic nations will, at one point, put their needs ahead of the nation's requirements.
To counter the lack of baby-making factories, many countries across the years have penalized individuals for not wanting to have children. Be it singles or married couples, they are all subjected to punitive taxes like the Bachelor Tax for their failure to be "good citizens" and baby-making factories for the nation's ever-growing capitalistic needs.
In Ancient Rome, around 9 AD, there existed a Bachelor Tax on men (ages 25-60) and women (20-50) if they were celibate, in order to promote marriage and if they refused to have children. Ottoman Empire as well, resorted to taxations: resm-i mücerred which was paid by the peasants and the poor of the state. England had a Marriage Duty Act of 1695 that taxed individuals over the age of 25 and was used to raise coin for the war against France. Although, the US resorted to tax unmarried men in Missouri and Montana, they largely failed several attempts to pass a similar bill across the states from 1825-1934.
Among the countries that passed Bachelor Taxes include:
Bulgaria (1925, 1943, 1968)
Finland (1935)
Germany (1915 & 1923)
Italy (1927)
Poland (1946)
Romania (1986)
Spain (1928)
South Africa (1919)
Soviet Union (1941)
Turkey (1949)
CRITICALLY ANALYZED
Assumptions
Marriage boosts population growth.
Married individuals are more socially responsible.
Single men are less economically contributive.
Family units reduce social instability.
Marriage strengthens national moral values.
Tax penalties will incentivize marriage.
Population growth ensures future workforce supply.
Unmarried citizens are avoiding civic duties.
Higher birth rates support economic development.
Marriage reduces state burden for elder care.
Target
Japan introducing Bachelor Tax for unmarried people and married people without children in April 2026.
Analysis
History shows that bachelor taxes haven’t worked as intended. In places like Fascist Italy, instead of boosting marriage or birth rates, both actually dropped after the tax was introduced.
These kinds of taxes often hit the wrong people the hardest—especially poorer, rural men—without really addressing the deeper social and economic issues at play.
They also tend to create a messy and expensive system just to track who's married, who isn’t, and whether someone is "in compliance," often costing more than the money they bring in.
At their core, bachelor taxes punish people for their personal choices. They can make life harder for singles, especially those in non-traditional relationships or who simply choose not to marry.
Worse, they shift the blame for declining marriage rates onto individuals—particularly young women—while ignoring bigger problems like job insecurity, rising living costs, and housing shortages.
In places like Japan, where livelihoods are particularly patriarchal, adding a bachelor tax would more likely be regressive towards women's upward mobility, setting Japan back a few more decades in Women's Equality Movements.
References:
Arnold-Baker, C. (2001). The companion to British history. Routledge.
Barnett, L. R. (2013, Winter). The attempts to tax bachelors in Michigan. Historical Society of Michigan, 18–19.
Chamie, J., & Mirkin, B. (2012, March 2). Childless by choice. YaleGlobal Online.
"Celula de bază a societăţii, oficial indivizibilă". (2009, March 13). Jurnalul Național. Archived from the original on February 11, 2015.
Consider plan of bachelor tax. (1934, April 23). Schenectady Gazette.
Coşgel, M. M. (2005). Efficiency and continuity in public finance: The Ottoman system of taxation. International Journal of Middle East Studies, 37(4), 567–586.
De Grazia, V. (1992). How fascism ruled women: Italy 1922–1945. University of California Press.
Eddleman, B. (2021, July 22). Missouri bicentennial minutes: The bachelor tax. KRCU Public Radio.
Foreign news: Bachelor tax. (1923, May 28). The Times.
Friedrich Hartmannsgruber. (2002). Die Regierung Hitler (Vol. 3). Oldenbourg.
Gibson, J. (1996). The hearth tax, other later Stuart tax lists, and the Association Oath Rolls. FFHS.
Gumuscu, O. (2004). Internal migrations in sixteenth-century Anatolia. Journal of Historical Geography, 30(2), 231–248.
HACI BEKTASH VELI'S SON: PIR SALTUK ZAVIYE FOUNDATION IN IRAN. (2009). Türk Kültürü ve Hacı Bektaş Veli Araştırma Dergisi, 50, 43–44.
Italian bachelor tax. (1927, February 11). The Times.
Italian bachelor tax. (1928, January 8). The Times.
Italian bachelor tax. (1928, March 15). The Times.
Jersey's bachelor's tax. (1898, February 13). The New York Times.
Kornhauser, M. E. (2012, July 12). Taxing bachelors in America: 1895–1939. Tulane Public Law Research Paper No. 17-7.
Long, G. (1875). Lex Papia Poppaea. In A dictionary of Greek and Roman antiquities (pp. 691–692).
Minervino, M. (2016, May 29). Impuesto a la soltería. La Nueva.
Montana man refuses to pay bachelor tax. (1924, May 23). Batavia Daily Times, 16.
Montana's bachelor tax declared void. (1922, January 12). Milwaukee Sentinel.
Motika, R. (1995). Türkische Wirtschafts- und Sozialgeschichte (1071–1920). Harrassowitz.
Pollard, J. (2005). The fascist experience in Italy (p. 81). Routledge.
Romanian pro-natalism by Max Rudert on Prezi. (n.d.). Prezi.com. Retrieved September 14, 2014, from
Roddam, R. (2020, July 9). Wyoming's first tax controversy: The proposed bachelor tax of 1890. 101.9 KING FM.
Semiz, Y. (2010). Turkey's population growth policy during the 1923–1950 period and the issue of compulsory marriage law (bachelor tax). Selçuk Üniversitesi Türkiyat Araştırmaları Dergisi, 27, 423–469.
Stanley, A. (1999, November 16). Vastogirardi journal: Blissful bachelorhood and the shrinking village. The New York Times.
Treggiari, S. (1993). Roman marriage: Iusti coniuges from the time of Cicero to the time of Ulpian. Clarendon Press.
Turda, M. (2009). The biology of war: Eugenics in Hungary, 1914–1918. Austrian History Yearbook, 40, 243–262.
The tax on bachelors. (1921, June). The Social Hygiene Bulletin, 8, 5.
Vryonis, S. (1969). The Byzantine legacy and Ottoman forms. Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 23/24, 251–308.